Unleashing the Power of the Broody Hen: Why it's Vital to Disrupt her Nesting Behavior
- Donna Weekes
- Feb 1
- 4 min read
Updated: Feb 25

A broody hen can be a captivating sight—nestled comfortably in her nesting box, feathers fluffed up, determined to hatch the next generation of chicks. However, not all hens display this behavior with the intention of nurturing eggs, making it essential for chicken keepers to take action. Breaking up a broody hen that isn't truly setting on eggs benefits both her health and the stability of your flock.
Understanding Broody Behavior
Broody behavior in hens is a natural instinct triggered by hormonal changes along with a strong maternal urge. This often occurs when hens are present in a nesting area and feel the need to sit on eggs—even when none are available. When a hen sits on her nest for an extended time, she enters a state known as broodiness.
Interestingly, a survey by the American Poultry Association found that around 70% of hens become broody at least once in their lifetime, exhibiting behaviors that can lead to serious health issues.
The Risks of Unbroken Broody Behavior
Keeping a broody hen nesting for too long can have negative impacts on her and the rest of the flock. The main concerns include:
Health Issues
A broody hen can face serious health complications and become malnourished with sitting on a nest. She obeys her calling to sit and in doing so, she will neglect herself for the good of her anticipated chicks. She eats, drinks and eliminates waste once or twice a day, at most. She will eat approximately 80% less feed and water daily, resulting in malnutrition and dehydration. In hot weather, she can get heat stroke and in cold weather can get hypothermia when sitting. Additionally, a broody hen may become increasingly dirty, attracting pests like mites and lice.
Impaired Egg Production
When a hen is broody, she generally stops laying eggs completely. This shift can affect her future laying cycles significantly. If a hen remains broody for too long, it could take weeks for her to resume normal laying. Studies have shown that hens that stay broody without eggs may reduce their laying productivity by as much as 30% in the subsequent months.
Disruption in Flock Order
Hens maintain a pecking order that can be thrown off by a broody hen. Her prolonged stay in a nesting box can prevent other hens from accessing nesting spaces, leading to stress and potential aggression among flock members. Her behavior often inspires other hens in the flock to brood.
Signs of a Broody Hen
Identifying a broody hen early is key to managing her behavior. Look for these signs:
Aggression: A broody hen may act territorial, puffing up her feathers and pecking at anyone who approaches her nest. For example, a hen might respond to a caretaker's presence by lunging or emitting threatening noises.
Squatting: If approached, a broody hen will often squat low, which signals her readiness to brood, even if no eggs are there.
Constant Clucking: Broody hens often make low, persistent clucking sounds, a behavior distinct from their usual vocalizations.
When and How to Break Up a Broody Hen
Once you determine a hen is broody without eggs, it's important to act quickly. A broody hen who is allowed to sit indefinitely can suffer long-term health consequences and even die from malnutrition or dehydration.
Here’s how you can effectively break her nesting behavior:
Timing Matters
Intervene as soon as possible. If you notice a hen sitting for over 24 hours without any eggs, it’s a clear sign that action is needed. Quick intervention could prevent long-term health problems.
Change of Environment
One effective method is to remove the hen from her nesting area and place her in a different environment. This could be a separate coop or your garage. Ensure this new area is well-ventilated, comfortable, and free from nesting materials to discourage her from returning to her previous behavior.
Use of a Broody Breaker
A broody breaker cage allows the hen to cool off her brood patch. A wire bottomed cage, raised up off the floor, placed in a well lit location away from the coop.
The wire bottomed cage allows cooler air to circulate under the hen, cooling off her brood patch on her abdomen. The key is an elevated, wire bottomed cage without litter, located away from the coop. She is kept in the Broody Breaker 24 hours a day until she is no longer broody, aka "broken up." It can take anywhere from 3 days to a week to break her up, depending how soon she was put in the broody breaker and how stubborn she is.
Ensuring Nutritional Health
When she is kept in the broody breaker continue with her regular diet, a nutritionally complete chicken feed and fresh water. To encourage a healthy return to normal behavior, provide a balanced diet rich in vitamins and minerals. Which would be her nutritionally complete chicken feed.
Also as an option to give her an extra boost, you can offer her Chick' N Swell Electrolytes, which will help with dehydration (broody hens drink 80% less) and/or Chick' N Swell Vitamins+, which will supply her with the necessary vitamins to get her health back to where it should be. Both products will help her get back on track nutritionally.
Visit Chick' N Swell for other products offered chicknswell.ca
Empower Yourself as a Chicken Keeper
Disrupting a broody hen that isn't actively hatching eggs is essential for her welfare and the overall health of your flock. Although breaking up natural behavior may seem harsh, the long-term benefits for both the hen and the flock outweigh the brief discomfort.
Recognizing the signs of a broody hen, understanding the risks involved, and taking appropriate action will help maintain a thriving and harmonious flock.
Managing the behavior of a broody hen is not the most pleasant task, but it is necessary. Equip yourself with knowledge and take decisive action. By doing so, you'll help ensure your hens remain healthy and productive.
Comments